Sponsored: This article is made possible by The Elijah Institute, supporting quality and engaging Catholic content.
There’s a quiet moment that happens sometimes in prayer. It’s that pause when the words dry up and what’s left is something simpler: a reaching out. We may not even know what we’re reaching for, only that we need Someone.
Psychologists have a name for that reaching: attachment behavior — the human drive to seek closeness, safety, and reassurance from someone we trust. It’s the instinct that makes a child run to her father after scraping her knee or a friend call someone they love when grief hits hard. But it’s also at the heart of our spiritual lives.
According to attachment theory, developed by John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth and expanded in later research, our earliest relationships with caregivers shape the patterns of connection that follow us into adulthood. The secure, anxious,avoidant, and fearful avoidant ways we bond with others don’t disappear when we start praying. They often reappear in how we relate to God, particularly during dark and desolate times.
That’s what Pehr Granqvist and Lee Kirkpatrick explore in “Attachment and Religious Representations and Behavior” from The Handbook of Attachment. Their work invites us to see that the God we love is also the God we attach to. Grace often works through the same relational pathways that once taught us how to love, fear, trust, or withdraw.
The Roots Beneath Our Faith
Attachment theory tells us that from infancy, we learn about the world through the presence—or absence—of reliable love. A securely attached child learns: “When I cry, someone comes.” An insecurely attached child learns: “Sometimes they come. Sometimes they don’t.” Or worse: “They never do.” And worst: “I brace myself with intense fear when I need them.”
Now imagine carrying those lessons into faith. A secure believer may instinctively trust that God hears prayers and loves unconditionally. A more anxious believer might worry constantly that they’ve disappointed Him. An avoidant believer might keep God at a polite distance, preferring ideas about Him to intimacy with Him. A fearful avoidant believer may fear any connection at all and stive to escape Him because the encounter always has shark music playing in the background.
Granqvist and Kirkpatrick show that these early emotional maps don’t define our relationship with God, but they do color it. Some people find in God a continuation of the trust they already knew, what the researchers call the correspondence pathway. Others discover in Him a healing substitute, a compensation pathway, when human attachments have failed.
In other words, for some of us, faith echoes our family story. For others, it rewrites it.
The God Who Steps Into Our Patterns
One of the most profound insights of the Christian faith is that God doesn’t wait for perfect circumstances to reveal Himself. He steps into the tangled web of human attachment, takes on flesh, and calls Himself Father.
Jesus speaks often of a love that can be trusted:
“Are not two sparrows sold for a penny? And yet not one of them falls to the ground without your Father knowing” (Matthew 10:29).
But He also acknowledges our fears:
“Do not let your hearts be troubled. Trust in God, trust also in me” (John 14:1).
In the light of attachment theory, those aren’t just spiritual slogans. They’re divine invitations to repattern how we love and are loved. The anxious heart hears, “You don’t need to earn My presence.” The avoidant heart hears, “You can let Me in.” The fearful heart hears, “You are safe.”
Grace doesn’t erase psychology. It informs, transforms, perfects, and fulfills it. God works through the very architecture of our relationships, teaching us through His faithfulness what others may have failed to teach us: that love can be steady.
When Faith Mirrors the Family
Consider how many times Scripture uses familial language: God as Father, Israel as His child, Christ as Bridegroom, the Church as Bride. The entire drama of salvation unfolds in relational terms.
Yet for many, those words can hurt before they heal. Someone who’s been betrayed by a father may flinch at the word “Father” in the Creed. Someone who’s known only abandonment might find “Abba” hard to say without a lump in the throat. Someone whose filial relationships frequently filled them with visceral fear as a child may even phobically avoid saying “Father” during any prayer.
This is where Granqvist and Kirkpatrick’s research touches something deeply pastoral. Our image of God isn’t formed in a vacuum. It grows in soil tilled by parents, peers, priests, and even our own interior dialogues.
If our first attachments taught us fear or uncertainty, then the journey of faith becomes a reattachment process, a journey toward “earned” security. In prayer, sacraments, and community, we learn slowly what it means to be securely held.
In that sense, confession can feel like returning home. Eucharistic adoration can feel like being seen and known. Spiritual direction or therapy can become sacred spaces where our fragmented stories find coherence under God’s gaze.
Healing Through the Safe Haven and Secure Base
As Christians can attest, life’s wounds are a difficult burden to carry. Though their faith cultivates interior freedom, wounds and traumas can leak into the present, sometimes frequently. Longsuffering servants of God generally know they require much healing, and many unfortunately despair in the effort and throw in the towel. There is no absolute certainty that they will triumph over their personal struggles or that their pain and suffering will transform this side of heaven. Yet faith still provides hope.
One of the key ideas in attachment theory is that felt security requires a “stronger, wiser other” attachment figure who provides a “safe haven” and “secure base”There is nothing stronger than God’s omnipotence and nothing wiser than God’s omniscience. This is a relationship to which we can return for comfort and from which we can explore the world (the external world as well as our internal psychological and spiritual world).
In theology, that “safe haven” is God Himself. “Under His wings you will find refuge” (Psalm 91:4).
The more securely we attach to God, the freer we become. Not because He removes our need for others, but because He perfects it. Secure attachment to God transforms how we love. It teaches us that vulnerability is not weakness and that intimacy isn’t something to fear.
Granqvist and Kirkpatrick note that secure believers tend to engage in prayer not as anxious pleading but as trusting dialogue. They can experience silence without panic and absence without despair. Their faith is resilient, not because life is easy, but because love has proven faithful. Consequently, God as their secure base edifies their prayer and encourages them along the lows of life
“Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil, for you are with me; your rod and your staff comfort me” (Psalm 23:4).
Grace Heals What Nature Couldn’t
Catholic theology holds that grace builds upon nature; it doesn’t replace it. If attachment wounds are part of our human nature, then grace has work to do there too.
This means the healing of our relationship with God isn’t just spiritual sentiment. It’s incarnational. It happens through bodies, memories, and experiences. Through faithful friendships. Through the Church as the Body of Christ. Through the Eucharist, which unites us physically to divine love.
The Catechism reminds us:
“God’s parental tenderness can also be expressed by the image of motherhood, which emphasizes God’s immanence, the intimacy between Creator and creature” (CCC 239).
Even when human love falters, divine love does not. The ultimate attachment figure we were made for has never abandoned us and never will.
Attachment and the Supernatural Encounter
Attachment theory can also shed light on our devotion to the saints. When a child grows, their circle of attachment figures expands—from parents to mentors, friends, and community. In the same way, our spiritual attachments widen: to Mary, to our patron saints, to those who intercede for us.
Far from being psychological crutches, these heavenly relationships reveal how God meets human needs through communion. The saints are models of secure attachment to God. They cling without fear, surrender without anxiety, and trust even through suffering. Unlike our earthly attachment figures, the saints, angels, and each Person of the Trinity can be called upon at any moment; their love is accessible 24/7.
Saint Thérèse of Lisieux, who often described herself as a child on the lap of the Father, once wrote, “It is confidence and nothing but confidence that must lead us to love.” In psychological language, she was describing a securely attached faith.
What This Means for the Church
If faith is, in part, an attachment relationship, then pastoral care should be attachment-informed. The Church becomes not just a place of doctrine but a sanctuary of safe haven and secure base experiences.
Attachment theory suggests that our attachment figures delighting in us every step of the way is essential for optimal security, whether in our return to God in our distress or being accompanied by him in our exploration. His divine and eternal delight in us radiates his tender love. It can help us to deeply know we are cherished even when we feel insignificant or invisible, valued even in the times we feel worthless, and loved despite feeling unlovable. The Church is called to this same delight and tenderness.
Every confession heard with gentleness, every homily that speaks of mercy, every Eucharist offered faithfully reinforces the message: “You are safe here. You are loved here. You can come home.”
For those who carry the wounds of inconsistent love, this is revolutionary. The sacraments are not abstract symbols but embodied reassurances—God’s consistent, reliable presence breaking through time and memory.
Returning to the Father
At its heart, the story of salvation is the story of secure attachment restored. We wandered, but the Father ran to meet us. We feared, but perfect love cast out fear. We doubted, but grace whispered again and again: “You are mine.”
Attachment to God is not a theory to memorize but a relationship to live. It is the rediscovery of the One who was never absent, the embrace that every other embrace dimly mirrors.
The more deeply we let ourselves be held, the more freely we can love others. In Him, our restless attachment systems finally find rest.
“For you are my refuge, my stronghold, my God in whom I trust.” — Psalm 91:2
Thanks again to today’s article sponsor, The Elijah Institute! Learn more about how they’re equipping Catholic mental health professionals to care for the whole person—body, mind, and soul—through integrated, faith-filled training at The Elijah Institute.
