Editor’s Note: Matthew Chicoine interviewed Shaun McAfee, via telephone on October 23, 2026. Some of the questions/answers may have been rearranged, edited, and paraphrased to provide the best reader experience without losing any integrity of the answers given.
What inspired you to write the Compendium of Eucharistic Miracles?
Great question! I’ll tell you the Eucharistic Miracles were a big part of my conversion. I remember the story of Saint Tarcicious. He is a third century Christian martyr. He guarded the sack of consecrated hosts. What this story said to me was the deeper truth. In every miracle, God is teaching us. In this story, the early Church was willing to die for the Eucharist. The miracles showed at different points in history that God
TAN had asked me to write this compendium but it didn’t really require much fuel for me to write since I was already drawn to these miracles.
Why do you think this book is needed today?
I personally feel we are coming down from the New Atheist movement. This group of people has left us alone after the death of Christopher Hitchens. Today I see a greater need to focus on the sacraments. We are now answering the questions of the historicity of our faith.
One of the ways we present the book is showing doctrine. We show how God unfolds the Eucharist over time. As ecumenism grows and we dialogue with our fellow Christians, it becomes important to discuss the Eucharist. We aren’t required to believe in the Eucharistic Miracles themselves but we are required to believe what they indicate. Not the elemental reality of the miracle but the fundamental reality of Jesus truly being present in the Eucharist.
The Church is being attacked at all angles, especially the sacrament. The Eucharist is the most necessary part of our faith. I think what we have to present in this book is a huge consternation to the modern religious environment.