A 1011 Word Interview with Shaun McAfee


Editor’s Note: Matthew Chicoine interviewed Shaun McAfee, via telephone on October 23, 2026. Some of the questions/answers may have been rearranged, edited, and paraphrased to provide the best reader experience without losing any integrity of the answers given.


What inspired you to write the Compendium of Eucharistic Miracles?

Great question! I’ll tell you the Eucharistic Miracles were a big part of my conversion. I remember the story of Saint Tarcicious. He is a third century Christian martyr. He guarded the sack of consecrated hosts. What this story said to me was the deeper truth. In every miracle, God is teaching us. In this story, the early Church was willing to die for the Eucharist. The miracles showed at different points in history that God

TAN had asked me to write this compendium but it didn’t really require much fuel for me to write since I was already drawn to these miracles.

Why do you think this book is needed today?

I personally feel we are coming down from the New Atheist movement. This group of people has left us alone after the death of Christopher Hitchens. Today I see a greater need to focus on the sacraments. We are now answering the questions of the historicity of our faith.

One of the ways we present the book is showing doctrine. We show how God unfolds the Eucharist over time. As ecumenism grows and we dialogue with our fellow Christians, it becomes important to discuss the Eucharist. We aren’t required to believe in the Eucharistic Miracles themselves but we are required to believe what they indicate. Not the elemental reality of the miracle but the fundamental reality of Jesus truly being present in the Eucharist.

The Church is being attacked at all angles, especially the sacrament. The Eucharist is the most necessary part of our faith. I think what we have to present in this book is a huge consternation to the modern religious environment.

Socks Religious

For those unfamiliar with the topic, what exactly is a Eucharistic miracle?

A miracle is a supernatural act, outside the laws of nature that can only be attributed to God. It might be supernatural healing. A Eucharistic miracle relates to the sacrament of the Eucharist. There’s bleeding miracles, there’s light emitting miracles, there are miraculous preservations of a consecrated host for a few hundred years. We also have miracles where there are visions of the Child Jesus being wounded and bleeding into the chalice. The Eucharistic Miracle confirms the teaching of the Eucharist.

How does the Church determine whether one is authentic?

Good question! There’s no straight answer to this. This has evolved over time as methodology has developed over time. You might not need 100 witnesses or a microscope. The Church sends the miracle to independent studies and analysis. The Church does all diligence possible to let the witness of the evidence stand on its own. And the Church will put in a theological inquiry to ensure there’s sound teaching involved in the miracle.

Because the Eucharistic Miracles are not part of the deposit of faith and it falls under private devotion it is not required to believe in them. They certainly help our faith. The Church will give a nihil obstat (nothing stands in the way) for the miracle given by the local bishop.

Your book includes more than 100 documented miracles spanning nearly two thousand years. Were there any accounts that surprised or moved you the most?

There’s a particular story in Ferrera, the host started to squirt out on the chapel ceiling. This was an interesting miracle! Another miracle occurred in the 11th century in Trani where a woman took a consecrated host to cook with and when it started to boil, blood came forth and flooded her house.

Did researching so many Eucharistic miracles change your own understanding or devotion to the Eucharist?

For sure! I’ve always had a deep faith and understanding of the Eucharist. But writing this book challenged my ability to articulate the teaching of the Eucharist. It really pushed my limit to take the Old Testament stories as typology and show how it was forecasting God’s plan on Calvary. This book pushed me to learn more about the lives of the saints and to see how the saints impacted our understanding and celebration of the Eucharist.

I pushed myself as an author and as a believer. I find myself at Adoration every week. I find myself, through the working of the Holy Spirit, trembling when I receive the Eucharist, especially after I receive Confession. This book took me from a firm understanding to a deeper and more participatory role worshipping God.

Some people are skeptical of miracle claims. What would you say to someone who approaches these accounts with doubt?

First I would say, open your mind. We don’t learn something profound just expecting it. Only when we least suspect it would be learned, do we have a word for this, an epiphany. Jesus tells us in John 6 that he is the bread of life. The miracles seem absurd but so were the words of Jesus. To any skeptic, I say keep searching for your answer. Don’t stop searching, there are satisfying answers to the Eucharist. They are miracles because we don’t have any scientific way to describe them. Keep searching and let the absurdity of the miracles compound in your heart.

The reason we call this the source and summit of our faith is because Jesus asks to eat Him in the Eucharist.

Real belief in the Eucharist changes your outlook on everything in life. I think that’s why it’s the summit of our faith.

The Eucharistic miracle in Lanciano, Italy (Photo: Junior / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain)

If someone only remembers one message after reading this book, what do you hope it is?

Participate in the Eucharistic Revival. I think the Catholic Church coming out of Covid is becoming refined. We are going to see a renewal of devotion in the Eucharist. Go and receive the Eucharist and receive well!

We’re hearing a great deal today about a ‘Eucharistic Revival.’ How do you hope this book contributes to that renewal of faith in the Real Presence?

Simply put, I hope it draws people to the sacredness of the host, and brings people to Eucharistic Adoration. I hope people get from this book a real interior change.

About Shaun

Shaun McAfee is a convert to the Catholic Faith and a Lay Dominican with the Central Province of St. Albert the Great. A veteran of the U.S. Air Force, he holds a Master of Business Administration from Liberty University, and a Master of Dogmatic Theology from Holy Apostles College and Seminary. He currently lives in New Orleans, Louisiana, with his wife, Jessica, and their seven kids.

Thank you for sharing!
Sacred Icons - Holyart.com
Catholic Balm Co

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.